September 28, 2004
No, He Knew That, Too
from - smijer
Via a Kos diary, I think this will be important. Among my friends is one Bush-backer who feels that no one else could have predicted the particular problems that are being faced in Iraq either. He feels that, since Bush couldn't have possibly predicted a Shia uprising, he really couldn't have planned for one. I don't know if the presence of realism in documents that Bush saw before the war will be enough to swing my bud, but I know that a lot of people are more apt to let Bush off the hook on the basis of "mistakes anyone could have made".
From where I sit, the whole idea is preposterous. Even if it was pure ignorance on Bush's part, surely plans could have been made based on worst case scenarios. Surely, a few extra months could have been spared to be sure of ourselves and to correct administration ignorance on points ranging from the existence of WMD to the likelihood of an insurgency. But there are others out there who honestly believe that Bush has been the victim of the same sort of mistakes that numerous other intelligence agencies and policy-makers fell to. There are others who sympathise with Bush on that score, who have bought into the meme that John Kerry lacks conviction, and who will vote for Bush in November.
Maybe, just maybe, between the debates and the publicization of the pre-war intelligence estimates that leave Bush without an excuse for not planning to occupy hell, a few more Bush leaners will start seeing things in a new light. We can only hope.
::Posted by smijer at September 28, 2004 07:31 AM
surely plans could have been made based on worst case scenarios.In my opinion when it comes to an invasion and occupation of a sovereign nation plans should ALWAYS be made based on worst case scenarios
John Kerry lacks convictionGeorge the younger has tunnel vision and it is described as being conviction and resolve. He may be sincere but he is sincerely wrong. The world community practically begged him not to go foward with the invasion of Iraq and there was ample evidence that what is happening now would happen.
Pleading ignorance at this stage of the game is a cop out.
| Posted by Buck on September 28, 2004 09:27 AM Link to comment |
My dad has that same myopia. He thinks that if the Republicans couldn't fix the economy, it couldn't be fixed. Ditto the deficit. And the Democrats would have made it worse.
Therefore, bad things under Republicans are the random whims of fate, which staunch Republicans handle to the best of human ability. And bad things under Democrats are the fault of Democrats, and would have been even worse if the Republicans hadn't been fighting at every turn.
On the other hand, he's looking at Kerry campaign literature....
| Posted by Morat on September 28, 2004 05:53 PM Link to comment |