February 08, 2006

How not to be taken seriously

from - RSA

So I'm reading an interview with Daniel Dennett in Salon, concerning belief in God. Dennett is an important figure in the philosophy of mind, and he's a great speaker and writer to boot. (I had dinner with Dennett once, and in the space of a five minute conversation he was able to provide significant guidance to my research.) I decide to read the letters to the editor, to see how his comments are taken, and the first letter includes this, from a disgruntled reader:

So, how does he come off not referring to my writings on this subject in his book? This is my original idea while he pretends it is his. This doesn't sound too kosher to me for an academic. Moreover, because it wasn't his idea he also doesn't understand the full implications of it and his book falls far short of what it should be. That you should be interviewing him instead of me is a disappointment because your readers aren't getting all they need to from this concept.

I love the complaint: Why is he famous instead of me?

::

Posted by RSA at February 8, 2006 05:06 PM
Comments

He should be embarrassed. What a pity.

univar.jpg Posted by smijer on February 8, 2006 09:08 PM
Link to comment

Interesting article.

Are you saying God is a product of our biology?

I'm saying that if God does not exist, many of us would believe in him anyway because of the way we have evolved, both genetically and culturally.


This quote threw me off a little bit. I would have thought he would have said, “Even though god does not exit” instead of “if God does not exist”.
In an interview with Alan Alda, you said the key to being happy is to find something larger than yourself and work for it. What are you working for?

Truth and freedom. These are terrible times and our ability to destroy the planet has never been greater. But if we can educate each other, listen to each other and learn more about each other -- and as long as we can preserve the free-society traditions of informed political discussions -- I think we have some hope


My belief in God is, to me, synonymous with a belief in Truth and Freedom. I do not see God as a man with a long white beard kicking ass and taking names. I believe that Truth and Freedom exist even though I cannot properly define either or put them in a bottle.
I am 100% behind Daniel C. Dennett and the work he is doing. I would urge him to continue in his study, keep careful notes and let the world know what he concludes. It is possible that he may wind up surprising himself.
univar.jpg Posted by Buck on February 9, 2006 08:49 AM
Link to comment
Comments for this entry are closed. Please leave your notes on a more recent comment thread.